When you need the very best expert in your corner

Articles & Insights

Perspectives on Forensic Chiropractic Consulting

Perspectives on forensic chiropractic consulting, professional standards of care, expert testimony, regulatory matters, and evidence-based clinical evaluation.

These articles explore issues relevant to attorneys, insurers, regulatory agencies, and healthcare professionals, with an emphasis on independent analysis, professional experience, and what the available evidence supports.

 

Evaluating the Chiropractic Standard of Care: An Evidence-Based Approach

The chiropractic standard of care is an important consideration in professional liability investigations, regulatory proceedings, and other matters involving the evaluation of clinical conduct. Yet determining whether a chiropractor's actions were consistent with the applicable standard is not always straightforward.

Chiropractic is a diverse profession, encompassing different treatment techniques, clinical philosophies, and approaches to patient management. Evaluating professional conduct requires an understanding of this diversity, along with a careful examination of the available evidence, relevant professional expectations, and the circumstances surrounding the care provided.

A standard-of-care opinion must be grounded in objective analysis rather than personal preferences, assumptions, or the eventual outcome of treatment.

The Diversity of Chiropractic Practice

An important consideration in evaluating the chiropractic standard of care is recognizing the diversity that exists within the profession itself. Chiropractic encompasses a broad range of philosophical perspectives, treatment techniques, and approaches to patient management.

Many chiropractors employ a combination of spinal manipulation, instrument-assisted adjustments, passive therapeutic modalities, and active rehabilitation. Others emphasize specific chiropractic techniques or practice within philosophical frameworks that differ from more conventional clinical approaches.

When evaluating chiropractic care, an expert must recognize that the provider's treatment philosophy may differ from their own. Such differences should not influence the expert's objectivity or the application of the appropriate standard of care.

A difference in treatment philosophy does not, by itself, establish a departure from the standard of care. Likewise, adherence to a particular chiropractic technique or philosophy does not automatically establish that the care provided was appropriate.

The fundamental question is not whether the expert would have treated the patient differently, but whether the chiropractor's conduct was consistent with the applicable professional standard under the same or similar circumstances.

Objectivity in Standard-of-Care Evaluations

Objectivity is fundamental to a standard-of-care evaluation. Each investigation should begin with an impartial review of the available evidence, without preconceived assumptions regarding the provider's conduct or the outcome of the case.

My evaluation involves a thorough examination of the relevant documentation. Depending on the circumstances, this may include prior medical records, chiropractic treatment records, diagnostic studies, interrogatories, patient and provider statements, and other pertinent information.

Understanding the patient's preexisting conditions, clinical presentation, examination findings, treatment decisions, and documented response to care provides the foundation for evaluating the chiropractor's conduct.

The expert must consider the clinical circumstances and professional expectations applicable at the time care was provided. The central question is whether the provider's decisions and actions were consistent with what a reasonably prudent chiropractor would have done under the same or similar circumstances.

Likewise, the expert's conclusions must be supported by the available evidence, whether that evidence supports compliance with, or a departure from, the applicable standard of care. In some investigations, the evidence may be insufficient to support a definitive conclusion.

Establishing the Applicable Standard of Care

Determining the applicable chiropractic standard of care requires a careful examination of the available professional and scientific evidence. Published clinical guidelines, peer-reviewed literature, chiropractic education, professional practices, and applicable statutes and regulations may all provide relevant information. However, these sources must be critically evaluated rather than accepted at face value.

Clinical practice guidelines can be particularly valuable, but their credibility depends on how they were developed. Important considerations include the organization responsible for the guideline, the methodology used in its development, the quality of the supporting scientific evidence, and whether philosophical or organizational biases may have influenced its recommendations.

The expert should also consider the nature of the supporting research, including systematic reviews, meta-analyses, scoping reviews, and consensus-based recommendations. Regardless of the methodology employed, the quality of the underlying evidence and its applicability to the clinical circumstances must be carefully evaluated.

Similarly, peer-reviewed research can contribute to an understanding of professional expectations, but publication alone does not establish scientific validity. Study design, methodological limitations, funding sources, potential conflicts of interest, and consistency with the broader scientific literature should be considered when evaluating the weight of published research.

Chiropractic education provides another important source of information regarding foundational clinical competencies and professional expectations. However, educational institutions may differ in their philosophical orientations and emphasis on particular treatment approaches. Consequently, the practices taught at a single institution should not automatically be considered representative of the entire profession.

State statutes and administrative regulations carry a different form of authority. They establish legally binding requirements within their respective jurisdictions and must be considered when evaluating professional conduct. Particular attention should be given to the statutory and regulatory requirements in effect at the time the care was provided.

No single source necessarily resolves every standard-of-care question. The expert must evaluate the available information collectively, considering its authority, reliability, and relevance to the specific circumstances. The resulting opinion should reflect a reasoned application of the applicable professional and legal standards to the facts of the individual case.

Clinical Judgment and Professional Responsibility

Differences in clinical judgment are common throughout healthcare, and chiropractic is no exception. Practitioners may reasonably differ in their selection of treatment techniques, frequency of visits, rehabilitation recommendations, and expectations regarding clinical outcomes. These differences do not automatically establish that one approach complies with the standard of care while another does not.

When evaluating treatment decisions, the expert should consider the patient's clinical presentation, relevant medical history, examination findings, treatment objectives, documented progress, and the clinical rationale supporting the care provided.

The expert must evaluate whether the provider's clinical decisions were reasonable under the circumstances and supported by the available evidence. Differences in treatment approaches should not be confused with departures from the standard of care, nor should the absence of a favorable clinical outcome automatically establish that the care was inappropriate.

Patient Safety Across Chiropractic Philosophies

Although chiropractic practitioners may differ in their treatment approaches, fundamental responsibilities concerning patient safety remain consistent.

Chiropractors have a professional responsibility to recognize clinically significant warning signs, identify contraindications to treatment, and determine when additional diagnostic evaluation or referral is necessary.

When a patient's presentation suggests a potentially serious underlying condition, the chiropractor must respond appropriately. Depending on the clinical circumstances, this may require further examination, diagnostic imaging, referral to another healthcare professional, or activation of emergency medical services.

Recognizing a clinical red flag is only part of the practitioner's responsibility. The chiropractor must also understand its significance and take appropriate action.

Similarly, the chiropractor must consider whether the proposed treatment is appropriate for the patient's condition and whether relevant contraindications warrant modification, postponement, or avoidance of a particular procedure.

These responsibilities are not eliminated because a chiropractor follows a specific treatment technique or philosophical approach.

The Importance of Case-Specific Analysis

No two chiropractic standard-of-care investigations are identical. Although the principles guiding an investigation may remain consistent, the clinical circumstances, available documentation, professional expectations, and applicable regulatory requirements must be evaluated individually.

An important distinction involves the relationship between an adverse clinical outcome, medical causation, and a departure from the standard of care.

The occurrence of an injury does not, by itself, establish that the chiropractor departed from the applicable standard of care. Similarly, an expert may determine that chiropractic treatment likely caused or contributed to an injury without necessarily concluding that the provider breached that standard.

These are separate questions requiring independent evaluation.

The expert must consider whether the provider's decisions and actions were reasonable based on the information available at the time care was delivered. Conclusions should not be driven solely by the eventual outcome or influenced by the benefit of hindsight.

Equally important is recognizing the limitations of the available evidence. In some investigations, the evidence may support a conclusion regarding medical causation while remaining insufficient to establish whether a departure from the standard of care occurred.

Recognizing the limitations of the available evidence is an essential component of an objective investigation. The expert's responsibility is to provide conclusions that are supported by the evidence while acknowledging circumstances in which a definitive opinion cannot reasonably be established.

Conclusion

Evaluating the chiropractic standard of care requires an understanding of the profession's diversity, the clinical circumstances surrounding the care provided, and the professional and legal standards applicable to the individual case.

Neither a particular treatment philosophy nor an expert's personal clinical preferences should determine whether a departure from the standard of care occurred. Rather, the expert must critically evaluate the available evidence and apply the appropriate professional standards to the circumstances under investigation.

A defensible standard-of-care opinion is grounded in an impartial, systematic evaluation of the evidence, with conclusions that reflect both what the evidence supports and the limitations of what can reasonably be established.

Scott Misek